The 1925 Sullivan, Indiana, Mine Explosion

By Jordan Bickett
Sullivan County, a county in the southwestern corner of Indiana is approximately 450 square miles in size. In 1920, the population of Sullivan County was just decreasing to roughly 30,000 people. Caucasian was the population’s predominant racial make up at the time.[1] Bordering the iconic Wabash River, Sullivan County was used for a multitude of different purposes at the beginning of the twentieth century.[2] A mixture of agriculture and industry stimulated its economy at the time. Similar to many other Indiana counties, there was a good portion of farming in the area through out the roaring twenties. There were also a lot of working class families living within the community as well, though. Merchants and miners lived in middle-class sized houses amongst the area. Several of these men who were minders worked at the City Coal Company mine;[3] A mine that provided stability to the community until its explosion.
            The most devastating mining accident in Indiana history took place in the city of Sullivan within Sullivan County on February 20th 1925. The accident occurred in the morning time around 10:45 am. It is reported that 121 men were working in the mine when the explosion took place and 51 of these men were fatally injured.[4] Although it is hard to pinpoint the exact cause, many, including the workers, suggest that a spark from machinery ignited a pocket of gas; this evoked the massive explosion within the City Coal Company mine. The explosion caused a collapse that smashed several workers and trapped many others without breathable air. The particular mine was considered small because it was only 320 feet deep. The City Coal Company had been running for roughly two years when the accident took place and the mine produced 1,000 tons of coal each day; most of this coal was exported to Chicago.[5]
 The United States Bureau of Mines at Vincennes rescue team was the first to major crew to respond. They began digging to retrieve the miners immediately after arrival but were unable to reach the scene of the disaster until an hour after it had occurred due to travel time. It then took the crew an additional 30 minutes to actually reach the trapped miners. Once the rescue team finally reached the bottom of the mine, the lengthy and extremely dangerous process of removing injured workers along with dead bodies began.[6] Rescue workers acquired gas masks and other protective equipment to ensure their own safety in the harsh conditions. Injured miners spoke about being trapped within the ruble for several hours; many of them were knocked unconscious during the disaster. When news of the devastating explosion began to spread shortly after the accident, people from the surrounding areas immediately took notice and began to crowd to the scene.[7]
Within the immediate community and the extended community of the Sullivan explosion, people reacted in a numerous amount of ways. Several areas raised money for the victim’s families while others focused on catering to the needs of the recue crews. Some even opened up their personal businesses to help the cause. Generally, Family members of the lodged miners responded in a rather understandably frantic manner. Tears ran down the faces of the frightened women and children as it was eventually revealed that 51 workers had perished in the horrific accident. Other members of the extended community reacted in a calmer and more resilient manner, though. Sullivan County, along with neighboring communities, united in order to bring relief after the devastation.
Most of the immediate relief was provided on a local level because of the close proximity that the local people had in relation to the mine. Several organizations of local women gathered early in the day to set up stations to accommodate those taking part in the rescue efforts. Their reaction time was nearly immediate after word of what had happened spread into the community rather quickly. These women offered up food for rescuers who were willing to put their lives on the line during this particular time of need.[8] Workers from neighboring mines helped out the professional rescue crew by volunteering to descend into the mine in order to take on the lengthy process of pulling out the dead bodies and trapped men who had been injured during the explosion. This proved to be a selfless act due to the dangerous nature of the task because of the gas and fumes that still inhibited the mine. The community rallied together in order to minimize the affects of the disaster despite the loss of their loved ones.
The local recovery efforts continued on the day of the disaster when several of Sullivan’s merchants allowed their stores to be used as make shift hospitals. Buildings that had previously been used for retail purposes were now being utilized as a place where wounded minors could receive medical treatment. It is reported that physicians from all over the area were ushered to the outskirt of Sullivan where the devastation occurred in order to provide first aid to the injured, as well. It seems as though each member of the community was willing to contribute in some aspect to lessen the effects of the unfortunate occurrence.[9]
After most massive disasters families of victims seek some sort of compensation, especially in situations like this. Sullivan was no different. Not only had the dependents lost a loved one, they also lost a source of income. It was announced on February 21st, just a day after the explosion, that a local insurance firm would protect dependents of the 51 miners who had been killed. A representative for the insurance company announced that $3,960 would be granted to each set of dependents in order to compensate for their losses. Because many families effected wouldn’t be able to pay for their deceased family member’s funeral, the insurance firm also gave the victims $100 towards a proper funeral.[10]
As the days passed after the explosion, Sullivan received assistance from well-known organizations that were far less localized and more prepared for such a catastrophe as compared to the Hoosiers within the community who did their best to help out. The Red Cross was present at the scene of the accident within a couple hours of the explosion. Not only did the Red Cross provide urgent relief during the initial crisis by setting up an immediate care tent, the organization also helped with the financial struggles that those who were involved would later face. When the Red Cross closed on February 26th, 18,000 dollars had already been raised in efforts to relieve people who suffering due to the explosion.[11]
The local government is essentially bound to respond and get involved after such a significantly devastating disaster. The accident in Sullivan began the push for stricter mine safety in Indiana because the previous standards had proven to not be efficient. After the legislature called a conference, several committees such as the United Mine Workers of America met in Indianapolis during the days following the accident. They gathered to discuss the tragedy and to formulate a plan of regarding the pressing issue that was mine safety. Senator George W. Sims of was a significant driving force in the push for safety for miners and within mines. It just so happens that Sims was born in Terre Haute, which is close in proximity to the explosion site. He introduced the mine safety bill to the senate; this safety bill set up stricter regulations and rules pertaining to mining. Sims was essentially another member of the community who was doing his part. The mine safety bill that was purposed included rules that intensify safety within mines through out the country.[12]
Implications of hidden structures within Sullivan are extremely present when you look at the relief efforts that took place after the explosion at City Coal Company mine. While the families of the victims took a step back to collect their emotions, other members of the community stepped forward to help with the necessary reparation. The United States Bureau of Mines at Vincennes rescue team pared with volunteer workers from neighboring mines worked together in order to recover those who were berried within the destruction. Local women played a crucial role on the day of the disaster by bringing relief to the rescue workers. Physicians from the community and neighboring communities came to provide medical assistance while merchants offered up their stores as a temporary venue for treatment. A local insurance firm gave cash compensation to dependents of the dead miners. This compensation money pared with donations from organizations such as the Red Cross and donations from people in neighboring areas helped achieve financial recovery for those who were crucially impacted. A senator from the area even acted as a voice for recovery and prevention. There was previously no blueprint for this type of cooperation amongst the community; however, Sullivan was capable of bouncing back from the tragedy due to the intertwined efforts of several different major role players.
On the day of January 20th 1925 and the weeks following, the community of Sullivan County Indiana and its surrounding counterparts joined together in a particular manner that perfectly emulates the social structures of the area that had previously been hidden. The wholesomeness and cooperation of the community during this short time period allowed for the potentially long lasting effects of the man-made disaster to be of less significant. This previously unseen social structure in the Sullivan County area only became available to analyze during a time of absolute crisis. Each member of the community appeared to have their own niche, which in tern brought the community together as a unit in a way that is not typical. For a community such as Sullivan County to be united in such strikingly successful manner is rather uncommon. The recovery process was much more dynamic and efficient due to the communities hidden social structure.
Changes regarding the government and social situations happened almost immediately after the tragedy occurred nearly one century ago. The previously mentioned mine safety, proposed by George W. Sims, was sent to the house in direct correlation with the accident that occurred in Sullivan County. The bill proposed several changes that can intensify safety for miners and prevent more tragedies of this nature from happening. These changes include an increased amount of inspections and ban machinery that requires gas engines. Also, the mine safety bill requires that a mine containing three of more persons have an additional exit in case of emergency.[13] Socially Sullivan County also undertook major social change after the man-made disaster. A community that had previously been normal in terms of social interaction became much more socially intertwined as a community once members were subliminally forced to work as one in order to bring relief. The explosion at City Coal Company mine temporarily changed the social structure of the area. Because of the catastrophe on January 20th 1925, Sullivan C



[1] "Publications." Census of Population and Housing. N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Mar. 2014.
[2] "Geography." Gazetteer Files. N.p., n.d. Web. 01 Mar. 2014.
[3] Conaway, John. "Sullivan County: A Bicentennial History in Images." County History. The History Press, n.d. Web. 04 Mar. 2014.
[4] Associated Press, “51 Killed in Mine Blast,” The Logansport Morning Press, February 21, 1925. P.1.
[5] ”17 Bodies Recovered in Mine Disaster,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 21,1925.P.1-2.
[6] Associated Press, “51 Killed in Mine Blast,” The Logansport Morning Press, February 21, 1925. P.1.
[7] “Mine Blast at Sullivan,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 20, 1925. P.1.
[8] Associated Press, “51 Killed in Mine Blast,” The Logansport Morning Press, February 21, 1925. P.1.

[9] “Mine Blast at Sullivan,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 20, 1925. P.1.
[10] ”17 Bodies Recovered in Mine Disaster,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 21,1925.P.1.
[11] “Probe of Mine Disaster Faults Until Inquest,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 27, 1927. P.1.
[12] “More Mine Saefty,” Kokomo Daily Tribune, February 23, 1925. P.14.

[13] “Probe of Mine Disaster Faults Until Inquest,” Logansport Pharos-Tribune, February 27, 1927. P.1.